The controversial new Severus Snape actor finds himself caught between activism and a franchise many activists say should be left behind.
Paapa Essiedu, HBO’s newly cast Severus Snape, is stirring more than just potions by signing an open letter supporting trans rights in the U.K.—a move many found admirable, but others are calling hypocritical given his new paycheck is coming from the Wizarding World, per IndieWire.
J.K. Rowling, still executive producer on the series, responded calmly, saying, “I don’t have the power to sack an actor from the series and I wouldn’t exercise it if I did,” per Variety.
The drama is splitting the Potterverse once again. Some fans see Essiedu’s statement as principled; others think it’s empty PR while still cashing in on a franchise trans activists have long asked people to boycott—including 2023’s blockbuster Hogwarts Legacy, which became a lightning rod over Rowling’s involvement.
Essiedu’s Statement: A Public Pledge, A Paycheck Too
Essiedu joined Harris Dickinson, Nicola Coughlan, and over 400 filmmakers in signing a letter circulated by Motive Pictures supporting trans, non-binary, and intersex communities in the U.K., per IndieWire. The letter read: “We must now urgently work to ensure that our trans, non-binary and intersex colleagues, collaborators and audiences are protected from discrimination and harassment.”
That show of solidarity followed Rowling’s public praise for a U.K. Supreme Court ruling defining gender legally by biology. It also came as Essiedu’s casting as Snape sparked backlash among Potter fans for allegedly contradicting the character’s pale description in the books, per Vulture.
Rowling’s Response: Still Stirring the Cauldron
Rowling addressed the letter directly, saying, “I don’t have the power to sack an actor from the series and I wouldn’t exercise it if I did,” and added, “I don’t believe in taking away people’s jobs or livelihoods because they hold legally protected beliefs that differ from mine,” per Variety.
Rowling’s critics point to her 2020 tweet—“If sex isn’t real, there’s no same-sex attraction”—as the flashpoint that triggered years of backlash, per Glamour. She has denied being transphobic, but her continued involvement in the franchise has led to boycotts of everything from the new series to games, theme park attractions, and merchandise. Despite the uproar, Warner Bros. has stood firm behind her, stating, “The series will only benefit from her involvement,” per Bounding Into Comics.
Potter Cast Reacts: Splinters in the Sorting Hat
Several stars from the original films and the Fantastic Beasts spinoffs have spoken out in defense of trans rights:
-
Emma Watson said, “Trans people are who they say they are and deserve to live their lives without being constantly questioned,” per Glamour.
-
Rupert Grint stated, “Trans women are women. Trans men are men. We should all be entitled to live with love and without judgement,” per The Week.
-
Eddie Redmayne added, “I disagree with Jo’s comments,” while affirming his support for trans communities.
Bonnie Wright recently encouraged the new cast to focus on the books and enjoy the process, but her recent podcast comments did not directly address the controversy.
John Lithgow’s Take: Dumbledore Is Minding His Own Business
John Lithgow, set to play Dumbledore in the HBO series, doesn’t seem interested in choosing sides. “I didn’t anticipate that,” he said of the backlash, adding, “Why should her personal views be my business?” per TVLine. A friend even sent him an open letter titled “Please Walk Away from Harry Potter.”
He read it. He didn’t walk.
What Now for the Reboot?
HBO’s reboot, marketed as a “faithful adaptation,” stars Paapa Essiedu as Snape, John Lithgow as Dumbledore, and Nick Frost as Hagrid. But the controversy around Essiedu’s dual role—as both public ally and private participant in a Rowling-led project—adds more drama to a franchise already under constant scrutiny. Some actors have even disabled Instagram comments to dodge the backlash.
Whether this reboot can conjure fresh magic or just more online firestorms remains to be seen. Essiedu may be standing for something—but he’s also standing on a platform built by someone many say they won’t support.
News compiled by Derek Gibbs and Steven “Edgar” Bubbles / Published on May 7, 2025
Sources:
-
IndieWire, “’Harry Potter’ Series’ Paapa Essiedu Signs Open Letter on Trans Rights,” April 30, 2025
-
Variety, “J.K. Rowling Says ‘I Wouldn’t’ Fire Paapa Essiedu From HBO’s ‘Harry Potter’ for Supporting Trans Rights,” May 5, 2025
-
BBC, “Harry Potter: HBO reveals first cast members for Harry Potter TV series,” April 14, 2025
-
Vulture, “The ‘Harry Potter’ TV Show’s Snape Casting Is Getting Messy,” April 23, 2025
-
Bounding Into Comics, “Warner Bros. Defends J.K. Rowling’s Involvement With ‘Harry Potter’ HBO Series,” April 25, 2025
-
GameRant, “HBO Harry Potter Series Actor Faces Fan Backlash Over Casting,” April 18, 2025
-
TVLine, “’Harry Potter’ Star John Lithgow Surprised by J.K. Rowling Controversy,” April 28, 2025
-
Glamour, “A Complete Breakdown of the J.K. Rowling Transgender-Comments Controversy,” June 11, 2020
-
The Week, “How the ‘Harry Potter’ author built her anti-trans reputation,” September 17, 2024
-
News18, “Bonnie Wright AKA Ginny Weasley Has THIS Advice For New Harry Potter Child Stars,” May 6, 2025